CFB Week 5: Georgia Must Improve to Earn a Three-Peat

Sep 30, 2023; Auburn, Alabama, USA; Georgia Bulldogs head coach Kirby Smart celebrates following the Bulldogs' 27-20 victory over Auburn, at Jordan-Hare Stadium. Mandatory Credit: John David Mercer-USA TODAY Sports
Sep 30, 2023; Auburn, Alabama, USA; Georgia Bulldogs head coach Kirby Smart celebrates following the Bulldogs' 27-20 victory over Auburn, at Jordan-Hare Stadium. Mandatory Credit: John David Mercer-USA TODAY Sports

At approximately the halfway point of College Football’s 2023 irregular version of so-called regular-season play, Georgia is on our mind. 

The two-time defending national champion held on to the AP’s Top 25 No. 1 sport for 16th consecutive time this week. But in their Week 5 game Saturday, the Dawgs struggled to  remain unbeaten (5-0) whil it extend a school record winning streak to 22 straight by struggling to a 27-20 win at Auburn.

These Dawgs are not the same bone-crunching team that dominated college football and stoked NFL rosters for the last two years.

For the second time in two Southeastern Conference games, Georgia trailed at halftime, this time against a team that has a so-so offense that benefits from the play-calling of Auburn coach Hugh Freeze, who kept the Dawgs zigging when they should zag much of the time.

Georgia coach Kirby Smart admits his team is hardly a runaway favorite to three-peat.

“I just think there’s a lot more parity in college football,” he said. “I don’t think there’s a great separation between anybody,” he said, meaning “among anybody.”

"Among" is not only grammatically correct, but a better representation of the crowded condition AMONG several teams who have a legitimate claim to being at the top, or at least among the top three, in the ratings.

The 2023 season is not another of those many seasons in which dominance was dictated or claimed by, say, two teams at a time. Choose your favorite pair:

*Georgia / Alabama

*Alabama / Clemson

*Ohio State / Alabama

Or pick any two of the above. This year a full house beats those pairs of recent years.

As an example, here is a look at results from games involving teams in the Top 25 last week. 

Check out AP's new Top 25 poll here

Friday, Sept. 29

No. 19 Oregon State 21, No. 10 Utah 7

Saturday, Sept. 30

No. 1 Georgia 27, Auburn 20

No. 2 Michigan 45, Nebraska 7

No. 3 Texas 40, No. 24 Kansas 14

No. 6 Penn State 41, Northwestern 13

No. 7 Washington 31, Arizona 24

No. 8 USC 48, Colorado 41

No. 9 Oregon 42, Stanford 6

No. 11 Notre Dame 21, No. 17 Duke 14

No. 12 Alabama 40, Mississippi State 17

No. 20 Ole Miss 55, No. 13 LSU 49

No. 14 Oklahoma 50, Iowa State 20

No. 21 Tennessee 41, South Carolina 20

Kentucky 33, No. 22 Florida 14

No. 23 Missouri 38, Vanderbilt 21

No. 25 Fresno State 27, Nevada 9

Starting from the preason, Georgia used impetus from two consecutive national championships to be the overwhelming No. 1 team, and the Bulldogs received 55 first-place votes last week. The other eight were scattered among five other teams – hence 2023 is the year of the "Among."

Yes, the door is open for another team to jump up and take to the top spot. But who among them has the cred?

No. 2 Michigan hammered Nebraska and has yet to be tested, but the best opponent the Wolverines have faced is Rutgers (4-1). Not clear as to when that test is coming up, since Michigan's remaining schedule seems friendly.

No. 3 Texas? Fun team to watch. The Longhorns beat Alabama, and, other than a sluggish start against Wyoming the next week, the Longhorns have been stampeding, although No. 24 Kansas hung around for a little while Saturday at Austin. Led by rising quarterback Quinn Ewers, Texas outgained the Jayhawks 661-260. This sets up a battle of unbeatens next week as the Longhorns host No. 14 Oklahoma in the final Big 12 edition of the Red River Rivalry.

This will be their first meeting with both teams unbeaten since 2011.

No. 4 Ohio State won’t jump to No. 1 during an off week, so hold your breath for a while there.

No. 5 Florida State was also off Saturday yet somehow lost some luster since LSU, the team that the Seminoles smashed, 45-14, to start the season, allowed 711 yards in a loss to No. 20 Mississippi. Now LSU, which started the season ranked No. 5 (depending on the polls), has two losses before heading into October.

No. 6 Penn State was not that impressive against Northwestern. Drew Allar and the Nittany Lions need to figure out how to get some chunk plays if they hope to keep pace with Ohio State in three weeks.

No. 7 Washington played its first close game of the season against Arizona, but won to remain perfect.

No. 9 Oregon, which brutalized Colorado a week earlier, smothered Stanford on Saturday, 42-6. 

After Week 5, there seems to be little difference between No. 1 Georgia and No. 11 Notre Dame. The Golden Domers managed a game-saving 95-yard touchdown drive led by Sam Hartman to beat No. 17 Duke, 17-14.

No. 12 Alabama. Wow, this is low for the Tide and coach Nick Saban lost his cool, but not the game in a 40-17 decision over Mississippi State. Alabama beat Mississippi schools by a combined 64-27, meaning the Crimson Tide is the favorite in the SEC West.

Summing it up: Georgia may not be dominant, but should be safe atop the ratings for now, at least. If the Bulldogs want to stay there they will need a convincing win against unbeaten Kentucky next week.

Fun while it lasted

Prime Time has lapsed as Coach Deion Sanders and his maimed but entertaining Colorado Buffs lost their second consecutive game, although they gave No. 8 USC all it wanted — the Trojans needed to recover a last-minute onsides kick to preserve a 48-41 win.

Defending Heisman-winner QB Caleb Williams and the Trojans pushed out to a 34-7 lead in the second quarter before Prime’s son, early season Heisman hopeful quarterback Shedeur Sanders, turned a blowout into a one-score game in the fourth quarter.

“It was a pleasure for me to play against him [Caleb Williams] and his head coach. I mean that was fun for me, it really was,” Deion Sanders said. “Probably didn’t look like it, but that was fun.”

Colorado amassed 564 yards, the most USC yielded in 18 games under coach Lincoln Riley, who insists his D is improved.

“When something doesn’t go our way, it doesn’t look like last year,” Riley told reporters. “Not to the trained eye.”

Still, as great as Williams is — he threw six TDs Saturday — can we take the Trojans seriously as a threat to unseat Georgia if we adhere to the saying “defenses win championships”?

This was the second straight week the Trojans failed to show a killer instinct, after allowing Arizona State to hang around the week before.

The Buffaloes are 3-2 after five games, good for a team that Vegas bet on winning only three games for the season.


Latest Player Notes

If that really was Drake Maye’s last game in Chapel Hill, it provided a fitting full-circle ending

UPDATED NOVEMBER 13, 2023 2:49 PMHere was Drake Maye in the middle of it all late Saturday night, in the middle of the kind ...

Shedeur Sanders closing in on CU Buffs single-season records through pain of all the sacks and hits

PUBLISHED November 13, 2023 at 12:38 p.m. | UPDATED: November 13, 2023 at 12:40 p.m.BOULDER — Shedeur Sanders is closing ...

Tenth Anniversary of Kick Six: Inside video, "Official" look at Historic Iron Bowl Shocker

Published Nov. 13, 2023, 6:00 a.m.By Creg Stephenson See and hear history behind Kick Six (excuse the ads, but this is ...

Goodman: Jimbo Fisher is out and Nick Saban wins again

Updated: Nov. 13, 2023, 10:00 a.m.|By Joseph GoodmanJimbo Fisher is out at Texas A&M, which goes to show that even when a ...

Huard on Huskies: Why a win over No. 10 Oregon St would be huge

The No. 5 UW Huskies’ quest to make the College Football Playoff went through the two-time defending Pac-12 champions on ...

USC’s loss to Oregon exposes clear flaws in program-building up front

EUGENE, Ore. — In January, Lincoln Riley was on the sidelines at SoFi for the College Football Playoff championship game, ...

Two years after winning school-record 12 games, Brady Hoke out as Aztecs football coach

Brady Hoke is out as San Diego State’s football coach.SDSU released a statement Monday morning saying that Hoke is retiring, ...

Oregon’s Bo Nix named Pac-12 offensive player of the week for third time in 2023

Oregon’s Bo Nix earned his third weekly honor from the Pac-12.Nix, who went 23 of 31 for a season-high 412 yards with four ...

Oregon Ducks’ head coach Dan Lanning mentioned as a leading candidate for Texas A&M job

Oregon Ducks head coach Dan Lanning has been mentioned as a leading candidate to replace Jimbo Fisher as coach of the Texas ...

After ‘tough day,’ Boise State AD searches for a football coach; defensive analyst promoted

Boise State athletic director Jeramiah Dickey was on the job for less than a week the last time he began a search for a football ...
See More Player Notes